Rich Immigrants Poor Citizens Book

I got this text for a class I took in college and only was assigned to read a fraction of it. So, when I looked at my bookshelf to see what I was going to read next, I decided to give this one a try. Mintz attempts to take a look at the religious, societal and moral reform that took place in the antebellum era of the United States. He attempts to take a balanced look at what was a somewhat fractured idea. Using religion to alleviate society's ills, and using different capitalist or societal run institutions to help the poor and destitute may seem like an oxymoron or a useless venture to those people of today, but this came from a time where if you saw a problem, you tried your best to fix it your self as opposed to lobbying it on the Senate floor (although there was plenty of that too). The result of these ideas and efforts can be seen in everything today from public education to the proper treatment of poverty stricken families.

Still, this book does have it's flaws. One of these is the organization and focus of the book. He barely mentions or goes into any detail on the possible reasons for all of these social ills in the first place. Why was there a sudden influx of immigration into the US? What caused the widespread poverty in many metropolitan areas? What effect did the Market Revolution have on the working class family? What was education like before the creation of some kind of public education system? These questions are not answered satisfactorily, if they are answered at all.

Another problem is the style of writing, namely, that it only takes a surface look at the problem, and gives a surface look at the solution. It may give a few dates and numbers, for context's sake, but this leads to a brief summarization of the many problems that plagued America during this time period. There are very few quotes from those people involved in the movement, indeed, very few people are looked at in any depth at all. For a book of this size, I can think of several others that do what this book does in even greater depth. If you want a book on the temperance movement that also looks at the influence on women's right to vote, read Last Call: Rise and Fall of Prohibition by Daniel Okrent. If you want to look at the history of public education and teaching in America, then I'd look at The Teacher Wars: A History of America's Most Embattled Profession by Dana Goldstein. Both of these books go into detail what Mintz covers only in a few pages, at best. I am sure that there are many more that can do what Mintz only barley attempts to do with regards to poverty, the Market revolution, and the other questions asked above. A simple search on Goodreads or Amazon will show that there are plenty.

For me, what makes me rate it what I do is the style of summation, over explanation. I read a book to see an author's opinion on what caused certain historical events, or to see what a person says about a controversial subject. Here however, little detail is given beyond dates and numbers. Therefore my number is two. Two out of five. If you want to read it, go ahead, but there are probably better books on a more specific topic worth your time.