Reviews for Dark Earth

The average rating for Dark Earth based on 2 reviews is 3 stars.

Review # 1 was written on 2013-11-04 00:00:00 Maureen Ellis It's been a looooooooong time since I've had to put a book down before finishing it. Kudos to the author for getting a book self published. To be honest, that is more that a lot of people will ever accomplish in the world of literature. Having said that, the story could do with some good editing. The copy I have looks like the author did a global find and replace of the word "and" and changed it for "&" It's very jarring to start your sentences with "&" I have an average American's grasp on grammar, sometimes I'm not that quick to pick up on what's going on. That I noticed multiple grammatical issues doesn't speak well. The characters never really developed for me. I often found myself wondering who was who in the book. Who was the villain, who should I be rooting for? Dialog was sometimes confusing. In the end, after 127 pages, I will be putting this book down. The story has potential but it looks like things fell apart as that story was crafted and placed on paper.

Review # 2 was written on 2020-11-16 00:00:00 Van Hartman This story was first published in Amazing Stories, July 1961. Let me start with a brief summation of the story: Calhoun, is a doctor who flies a Med Ship. He has an assistant, Mergatroyd, a Tormal, which is a creature who can quickly develop antibodies from any virus he contracts, from which his antibodies can be analyzed and an antigen developed. In this story, the planet Weald 3 has vast stores of grain. The planet Dara is in a perpetual famine. The problem is with Dara's history'decades prior they had a planet-wide plague that passed along blue patches on skin on those people who contracted the virus, and thereby passed the anomaly to their decedents. To make matters more interesting, Weald 3 has an irrational and over-riding fear of contracting the virus from Dara. And now enter Doctor Calhoun and Mergatroyd to solve the problem. The following passages made my skin crawl with eerie parallels to today's world: "They had a plague on Dara, once. They're accused of still having it ready for export." The virus "only took hold of people in terribly bad physical condition . . ." ". . . if they do not cooperate in medical inspection . . . I can put your planet under quarantine and your space commerce will be cut off like that!" "When the blue plague appeared on the planet of Dara, fear struck nearby worlds. The fear led to a hate that threatened the lives of millions and endangered the Galactic peace." I barely got past the first page when this story became eerily parallel to this year, 2020. Overall, this was a good science fiction novella. 🪐 🚀 Recommended. This story was also published under the title This World Is Taboo. 🟣