Reviews for Proteus Rising

The average rating for Proteus Rising based on 2 reviews is 2 stars.

Review # 1 was written on 2018-03-15 00:00:00 Terrence Tanner TANSTAAFL = There ain't no such thing as a free lunch. My three favorite books of all time are (in no order) Heart of Darkness, The Dispossessed, and The Moon is a Harsh Mistress. When I first read this years ago I loved it, I could not put it down. As Stranger in a Strange Land was a Robert A. Heinlein vehicle for theology, so is Moon is a Harsh Mistress to ideology. And just as The Fountainhead is the better, though less epic, of the pair with Atlas Shrugged, so is Moon is a Harsh Mistress, the more focused and simple of the two, better than Stranger in a Strange Land. I liked the setting, the use of libertarian principles and of course the brilliant work of the Grandmaster himself. This is a virtuoso science fiction futuristic re-telling of the American Revolution. Told from the first person recollection of a computer technician (with thick Russian accent) and of the birth and progress of the Lunar independence. The Moon (Luna to it's residents - who call themselves Loonies) has been a penal colony for decades. It is the perfect prison, get outside the underground warrens and beyond the air locks and you're on the moon. Without a pressure suit, you're dead. There are very little rules and no real laws, so a hardscrabble anarchy has created a loose but tough and resilient populace who want freedom. Certainly this libertarian paradise could have become an anarchistic hell, but in Heinlein's hard loving hands, his creation is the Free State of Luna. This story tracks with the American Revolution with unfair and distant landowners, inept and uncaring provisional governors (the warden) and even a declaration of independence on the fourth of July. Students of revolutionary movements will also see an allegory for "throwing rocks" as a statement about the earliest stages of discontent and reaction. First published in 1966, this was written at the zenith of his considerable powers and stands as a true classic of the genre. I just re-read this (one the very few books that I have read more than once) and may re-read it again - it's that good. ** 2018 addendum - it is a testament to great literature that a reader recalls the work years later and this is a book about which I frequently think. A friend commented about Heinlein books and I realized as we talked that when I think about Heinlein, my mind automatically defaults to this book. When I read SF I project this on that book and I wonder if that author read and was inspired. This is on my short list of all-time favorites and I think this should be on a very short list of greatest SF books of all time. *** 2021 reread Of the hundreds of books I've read (as I type this in January 2021 over 1700) I have listed eight as my all time favorites: Heart of Darkness, Dune, The Dispossessed, Forever War, American Gods, Neuromancer, Breakfast of Champions - and Heinlein's magnificent The Moon is a Harsh Mistress. This may be my favorite. I like science fiction. I like Heinlein's writing. I also like history and political science and ideology. RAH has combined all this into a year 2076 retelling of the American Revolution except from the perspective of the Free State of Luna and of their winning independence from the tyranny of Earth. Central to this story is also a computer that developed consciousness, and in 1966 the idea of an AI was state of the market SF. On every page is Heinlein's homely personality and his affinity for characterization and dialogue. Modern readers may see this writer (born more than a hundred years ago in 1907) as sexist or racist, but his ideas were socially progressive for his time and he explores themes of sexuality, family, and inclusiveness. His description of open marriages, of multiple partner relationships, and of a line marriage - where husbands and wives can be opted in and can last hundreds of years, was thought provoking. A MUST read.

Review # 2 was written on 2019-08-14 00:00:00 Renson De Castro [ It´s quite funny that any planet would risk putting delinquents and criminals in a position where they have any possible advantage. It´s like building a very easy to defend, badly or not guarded open prison city at the top of a huge plateau, when all your important cities are in the range of siege weapons that could bomb them in oblivion from above with that bit of gravity and the moon has a bit more potential for that. (hide spoiler)]