Reviews for Takeover in Tehran: The Inside Story of the 1979 U. S. Embassy Capture

The average rating for Takeover in Tehran: The Inside Story of the 1979 U. S. Embassy Capture based on 2 reviews is 3.5 stars.

Review # 1 was written on 2012-04-25 00:00:00 Jesse Zacson This is not a good book. Ebtekar comes off pretty much as described in other sources -- a humorless true believer, tiresome and gratingly one-note as most extremely political and religious people are. This is more political tract than a participant's account of the Embassy takeover, and moreover it is a badly written one. I'm not sure why that should be, as Ebtekar didn't write the book herself: it's an "as told to" by a journalist named Fred Reed, and so I can't figure out how stuff like this ended up in here: "[In his memoirs hostage Rocky Sickman] comments on the friendly relations that developed between many of the hostages and the students, which gave the lie to the propaganda then circling the globe. Of that label used to malign Swedish humanitarianism, the 'Stockholm Syndrome,' not a trace was to be found" (p. 144). Uh... what? What does that even mean??? There is quite a bit of weird stuff like that in this book, bizarre comments and odd diction that can't be explained away as language barrier issues, as Ebtekar speaks fluent English and presumably Fred Reed does too. Okay, but that being said, despite its not being good, I still found this book useful. Ebtekar does seem like an unlikeable ideologue, but she is no dummy, and there are admirable things about her: she is certainly intelligent and courageous. One thing that was interesting to me in reading other hostage crisis accounts was how Ebtekar is inevitably portrayed in them as a chubby, ugly, and unpleasant woman -- in other words, she's insulted not just for her role as a fundamentalist spokesperson for the hostage takers, but for not being sexually attractive. (One source cited by David Harris memorably describes her as "a dour young woman with a horsey face that looked out from under a homely scarf [with a] miserable rabbit-like demeanor" -- mixed animal metaphors I can't recall being applied to male hostage takers.) Although Ebtekar doesn't address this in her book, I think it supports her criticism of women's position in the secular west. To her credit, she doesn't try to pretend that her own culture isn't also demeaning to women, but she feels that Islam itself is not, and argues that it is vastly preferable to western-style feminism. One thing this book really emphasized is how the students were kids. Unlike American sources who highlight their ignorance and perceived ineptitude, what Ebketar got across most was their somewhat naive idealism. While acknowledging that they were in many ways in over their heads, she has done the math, decades later, on what the students did, and concludes that it was a good thing. Without agreeing with her, I will admit that I can see her point of view, and what was good about this book was that it showed me the students' perspective in a way that I haven't seen in the American-penned accounts I've been reading. I can't really recommend this book, but I guess I'm glad that I read it.

Review # 2 was written on 2012-12-19 00:00:00 Sherri Lafrance I think this is an informative book . It gave me a different perspective of international affairs and the role of our government in global developments. I like her way of describing the life of the students and hostages together and the mentality of both. This book tells us that what we have learned about Iran and their Islamic revolution is very different from the perspective that Iranians themselves have. Massoumeh has much to say when it comes to understanding the reasons behind so much anti American sentiments and anger in Iran. I did not know that our government has been involved so deeply in the affairs of other nations and how they have ruined the livelihoods and future of other peoples. I see things now in a different light and I hope other American citizens would take time to read about this important event. After reading Takeover in Tehran I learned that many professors of international relations are now advising their students to read this book and to discuss its different view point.