Reviews for Philosophy--East and West

The average rating for Philosophy--East and West based on 2 reviews is 5 stars.

Review # 1 was written on 2016-08-22 00:00:00 Michael Obraske In the 1970s, tropical marine ecologist Bob Johannes set out to document the traditional knowledge of Palauan fishermen about the behavior and biology of the fish in the waters around Palau. It was a fairly radical idea at the time, and other scientists laughed at him'science so often being far too quick to reject any idea not generated in a laboratory and published in a peer-reviewed journal'but Johannes reasoned that the people of Palau, who for most of history had depended on fish for their survival, had spent their entire lives, for generations, following fish, catching fish, and learning about fish. Traditional fishermen in Palau spent decades perfecting their craft, and could not be considered masters until they were well into middle age. A marine biologist could never hope to gain such extensive and specific knowledge about such a wide range of species even over the course of a career. And Johannes's idea turned out to be a sound one; he collected vast amounts of new information about spawning and feeding behavior, enough to prompt decades worth of further study. His publication of Words of the Lagoon "helped highlight the importance of indigenous knowledge and community-based systems as key factors in marine conservation." Besides straightforward fish biology, Johannes also explored the ways in which the interruption of traditional fishing practices and law have directly impacted marine conservation in Palau (most notably during the Japanese occupation of the country during WWII, when the reefs were massively overfished to feed the new influx of people, and hyper-local tribal laws which would have conserved marine resources for future generations were superseded by the invading force; post-occupation the availability of cheap imported goods and the devastation of the reefs made traditional fishing financially unviable, leading to a loss of knowledge in younger generations and a vicious feedback loop resulting in more and more overfishing and rapid declines in marine resources). It's now considered a seminal work in the field and is still used as a graduate-level text in "fisheries, ocean policy, and maritime anthropology courses around the world." For the lay reader it is perhaps not uniformly fascinating (I have to admit I skipped the fishhook chapter), but I think it does contain enough in the way of colorful anecdotes, lucid journalism, and accessible science writing to make it interesting to a general audience. This review is also posted on my blog, Around the World in 2000 Books.

Review # 2 was written on 2013-04-11 00:00:00 Gary Stavropoulos Maybe cliche to say, but this book changed my life. After being so inspired by this brilliant work, I changed my career path from coral reef ecology to anthropology.