Reviews for Lizzie Newton and the San Francisco Earthquake (History Speaks: Picture Books Plus Reader's ...

The average rating for Lizzie Newton and the San Francisco Earthquake (History Speaks: Picture Books Plus Reader's ... based on 2 reviews is 3.5 stars.

Review # 1 was written on 2018-06-25 00:00:00 Stephen Romano Lizzie Newton and the San Francisco Earthquake is a good book to help children understand how the earthquake affected the city of SF in a way that kids will understand. I recommend adding it to 4th grade California History curriculum.

Review # 2 was written on 2015-06-20 00:00:00 Daco Solidus An educational picture book that tells about the San Francisco Earthquake of 1906 and what happened there. Lizzie was an interesting character, but at times I found her foolish or unrealistic. But she was also brave to go to her parents house on her own and also trying to help out people on the way to her house. During the time she helps out people she learns a heartbreaking lesson that is bound to follow her for her life. The story has quite a few facts, but shies away from the gruesomeness that was that day in history. Which isn't bad, as this is still a children's book, and I can imagine that this is already a bit scary, no need to add dead or dying people to the book as well. After all the illustrations we also have a small history lesson with some photographs and last (though something I didn't care about) a theatre play/performance. I haven't read that part, I already read the book, I didn't feel the need to read it again but this time in script form. The illustrations were really pretty, but not always good (figures looking distorted). But in general the author did well to capture the emotions that the characters had and also shows us the destruction that happened in the city. The ending, while of course sad, was also happy. At least for Lizzie and her parents. I really did like what Lizzie's parents did for the community. Would I recommend this book? Yes, even though I have it 3 stars, I would still recommend this one to everyone. Review first posted at