Reviews for General A. P. Hill: The Story of a Confederate Warrior

The average rating for General A. P. Hill: The Story of a Confederate Warrior based on 2 reviews is 5 stars.

Review # 1 was written on 2014-04-13 00:00:00 David Dozal Initially, I did not think that I would like Ambrose Powell Hill, chiefly because I adore Stonewall Jackson and was not pleased with how Hill had acted toward Jackson. However, after reading this, I really came to know and understand Hill! He was a sensitive man, a loving husband and father, and a great division commander--far better than he was a corps commander. He was just better at leading his men when he could be a part of the action. My heart goes out to this poor guy. He died an unfortunate and completely unnecessary death only hours before Lee's army began its march to surrender, he was plagued with an illness that continuously reoccurred and ultimately damaged the quality of his life in his final months, and he never seemed to receive the respect and honor that he deserved. An example of this provided by Robertson is where, years after his death in a Civil War site book, one author neglected to mention the monument of A. P. Hill altogether. Another thing that struck me oddly was that, although his wife loved him dearly, she remarried after his death. Of course, in that time period people usually remarried after the death of a spouse, but with a lot of other important generals who died fighting for the Lost Cause, the wife would not remarry. Stonewall Jackson's wife, Anna, was an example of that. It seemed as though Hill was extremely unappreciated, which naturally makes me far more supportive of him, although I didn't feel that way until I neared the end of the book because of my previous convictions. I would recommend this book to anyone interested in the Civil War, because this definitely completes a ton of the information that I lacked. It's also extremely readable. I regret that I went into the book with a dislike for Hill, because that ruined for me a lot of the points at which I should have felt compassion rather than contempt!!

Review # 2 was written on 2008-02-26 00:00:00 Eric Hubbard Hill is a strangely modern and tragic character. As a lieutenant in the U.S army he was stationed in Florida during various conflicts with the Seminoles, yet in contrast to the usual racism of the time he was sympathetic to the Indians, noting that all they wanted was to be left alone. Possibly as a result of the stress of his duties he took to drink, though he later regained more moderate habits after he was transferred to other theaters. Sent in at the tail end of the Mexican War, he called the conflict unjust. Hill neither owned slaves nor cared for slavery, yet as a Virginian and a Southerner, he found he could not fight anywhere else except under Lee. Still a lieutenant at the outbreak of the Civil War, he was promoted faster than practically any man in the Southern Army, making Brigadier General in nine months. Within the next year he was promoted to Lieutenant General, and in the last year of the war he was, despite poor health, Lee's second-in-command. Very early on Hill gained a reputation as an excellent trainer of troops, and his thorough work was apparent at the Battle of Bull Run, a conflict in which both sides dissolved into a pair of disorderly mobs ineffectually shoving at each other. The tide turned when Kirby Smith's brigade arrived, kept both discipline and order and smashed the Union right, thus starting the famous rout. Few knew that the training of that brigade had been nearly all the work of its senior colonel, A. P. Hill. However, the army's commander, Joe Johnston took note and put Hill first on the promotion list for a general's slot. Nor would this be the first occasion Hill's superiors would receive credit for Hill's efforts. During the Seven Day's fighting around Richmond, Hill's troops bore the bulk of the weight of the conflict, and his division took thirty percent casualties, gained itself a name as Hill's Light Division along with much praise in the newspapers, and earned the jealous wrath of James Longstreet. This conflict was caused because Longstreet failed to show up for the battle at Beaverdam Creek, thus leaving Hill in the lurch, then failed to show up at the battle of Gaines' Mill, leaving Hill in the lurch yet again as Longstreet thrashed around in the underbrush for several hours unable to get a battle line formed. Longstreet's troops only entered the conflict when Hill came over to Longstreet's position and ordered Hood's brigade (of Longstreet's division) to attack, a blow which resulted in the collapse of the Union line. Given the task of pursuing the now-retreating Federals, Lee assigned Hill command of Longstreet's troops for a while because Longstreet had vanished (despite the obvious importance of rescuing Richmond and staying on goal--you can only wonder what Longstreet was thinking). A Richmond newspaper praised Hill a little too much for Longstreet's taste, and embarrassingly, noticed the oddness of Hill being in charge of Longstreet's own troops for a time. Longstreet exploded and arrested Hill, but only to back off when Hill challenged him to a duel. After this behavior, Hill had had enough and refused to serve under Longstreet again. Transferring to Stonewall Jackson's corps, however, was only going from the frying pan into the fire. It wasn't long before Hill collided with Jackson's ego. Hill's troops rescued Jackson from a virtual rout at the Battle of Cedar Mountain when the Federals inconveniently decided to attack sooner than Jackson had been planning. This led to further ill-feeling when Jackson discovered his own Stonewall brigade had been the first to collapse, and the only body of troops, nominally Jackson's own, that distinguished itself in the fighting was Hill's former regiment, the 13th Virginia. Jackson finally lost it, clapped Hill under arrest though refusing to charge him with anything, (a situation illegal according to military law.) Wrathful but still dutiful, Hill swallowed his pride, talked his way back into command and fought the entire Maryland campaign while technically still in a state of arrest. His troops bore the weight of the fighting at 2nd Manassas and Chantilly, and his division inflicted the coup de grace at Harper's Ferry by flanking the enemy out of the fortifications. As a capper, Hill rescued Lee's entire army at Antietam. Reinstated after pressure from Lee, Hill and Jackson feuded all the way until Jackson's death. In the last year of the war Hill had a vital role in preserving the deteriorating Confederate morale in the trench warfare around Petersburg, though his health was failing badly. The reader is left with the subtle impression that Hill was more important in this respect than Lee himself was. The date of the significant decline of conditions in Lee's trenches starts exactly when Hill was forced to take prolonged sick leave. Hill's end could have been written by a Greek tragedian. In the last few days of the war he was shot directly through the heart and died trying to rally his troops when Grant finally broke the Confederate lines. Robertson's book is a fascinating read but it would be best if supplemented by other Civil War books, especially those dealing with the specific battles Hill fought. The Southern mythos has got Hill mostly wrong, and needs better scholarship and a more hard-nosed attitude about giants such as Lee, Longstreet, and Jackson. Too often historians trying to preserve the reputations of the aforementioned trio try to diminish Hill's. It is part of the Southern mythos that Lee was loved by his troops. But one of Lee's soldiers stated in a memoir that though Lee was respected by his troops, he wasn't loved. Lee was simply too formal, cold, and distant to inspire that sort of tender emotion. Hill, Robertson makes plain, was loved by his men.