Reviews for The Best American Nonrequired Reading 2008

The average rating for The Best American Nonrequired Reading 2008 based on 2 reviews is 3.5 stars.

Review # 1 was written on 2008-11-12 00:00:00 Mark Mckeown This is by far the weakest collection I've read since '05. Honestly, the best part was the throwaway "best of" craziness in the first third of the collection. I found the nonfiction tedious and "trying too hard" (including the Saunders piece . . though I did read it until the end . . . President Clinton makes me feel like a lazy ass) I found the fiction so-so at best. The comics were good. To be sure, "A Brutal Sweetness" by Abby Nance (it was mentioned in the back as a notable) was better than all of these pieces combined.

Review # 2 was written on 2008-10-31 00:00:00 Jason Williams As today is anthology review day, I just want to take the opportunity to pimp this one, and the whole series. Review follows: Once again this series, always the star of the "Best American" anthologies, delivers the goods. Here is just a selection of the delights it offers this year: A hilarious introduction by Judy Blume Best American police blotter items from Kensington, California Best American facebook groups Best American NY Times headlines from 1907 ("Man pours molten lead into own ear - believed to have been reading Hamlet"; "President's quiet Sunday: He goes to church, Greets neighbors, Has shot only rabbits"; "Have you a fetich? Most of us have") Best American: last sentences of books, Ron Paul facts, champion showdog names, Kurt Vonnegut writings, diary of a young girl, diary of the living dead. pieces by Marjorie Celona, J. Malcolm Garcia, Andrew Sean Greer, Helon Habila, Raffi Khatchadourian, Stephen King, Emily Raboteau, George Saunders, jake Swearingen, Patrick Tobin, Laura van den Berg, Gene Weingarten, Laurie Weeks, and Malerie Willens an excerpt from Paul Hornschemeier's graphic novel, "The Three Paradoxes" an illustrated story by Rutu Modan: "Queen of the Scottish Fairies" When I say that this anthology "delivers the goods", what I mean is - of the eight pieces I've read thus far, each has been fascinating, well-written, and not something I would otherwise have come across. (Other than one piece from each of The New Yorker, The new York Times, and The Washington Post, the selection is deliberately weighted to represent non-mainstream publications, such as The Paris Review, The Kenyon Review, The Virginia Quarterly Review, Zoetrope). J. Malcolm Garcia's "The White Train", about the cartoneros of Buenos Aires (people who, following the economic collapse of 2001, have been forced to make a living from recycling cardboard and paper) and George Saunder's portrait, "Bill Clinton, Public Citizen" (a fascinating account of the Clinton Foundation's work throughout the developing world) -- these two pieces alone are so good, they make it worth the price of admission. What this series manages to do, reliably, is to track down material that may be a little off the beaten path, but that is compulsively readable, and that expands the reader's horizons in the most enjoyable way possible. Starting each piece is like biting into an exotically flavored Dove bar - unfamiliar at first, but totally delicious. This anthology rocks!