Reviews for Empires of Intelligence: Security Services and Colonial Disorder after 1914

The average rating for Empires of Intelligence: Security Services and Colonial Disorder after 1914 based on 2 reviews is 4 stars.

Review # 1 was written on 2018-08-22 00:00:00 Chelsea Cox This book is a history of British and French colonial rule in the Middle East and North Africa (with bits of sub-Saharan Africa discussed in context) interwoven with the history of the the evolution and development of the colonial security services. The book starts off as if its going to be very dry and pedantic, but the narrative shakes itself off and loosens up a bit as it goes along. Overall, it makes for a very interesting read - the narrative about leveraging support of experts in the social sciences at the turn of the century to focus and drive intelligence collection makes for a good comparison to how we attempted to leverage such support in Iraq and Afghanistan (and for those who pay attention to such things, you can also compare the both to Vietnam-era social science efforts at SORO etc.). The time period focused on by the author also traces the development of SIGINT and IMINT as companion disciplines to the traditional spectrum of HUMINT collection - the book describes challenges as the countries shift employment of the emerging intelligence fields from the conventional high-intensity warfare of WWI to supporting counterinsurgency and suppression of dissent in colonial territories. The struggle in attempting to maintain population control in tribal socities with extremely small force numbers as well as operational conflicts between the use of lethal and non-lethal means of control reflect - in a very different context - some of the same problems we saw in operations in Iraq and Afghanistan. The solid narrative is also supported by extensive source notes and a good bibiliography. This includes leads on several obscure but potentially useful articles, papers and books related to intelligence in support of counterinsurgency and the suppression of dissent in tribal societies. This, by itself, gives the book value in my eyes. Definitely a recommended read for intelligence professionals as well as those interested in this particular period of history in the region.

Review # 2 was written on 2011-04-08 00:00:00 Beverly Titel Reading this book a second time made me appreciate Thomas's take on viewing history through the lens of intelligence services. Gives diplomatic history, normally a dreary and stuffy affair, a revitalization.