Reviews for Spindle's End

The average rating for Spindle's End based on 2 reviews is 4.5 stars.

Review # 1 was written on 2013-03-08 00:00:00 James Mulder Final review, first posted on Fantasy Literature: Spindle's End is long and leisurely-paced, but I found it an absorbing retelling of the Sleeping Beauty fairy tale, with fascinating details and appealing animals (Robin McKinley excels at both of those things) and a few major twists to the classic story. I enjoyed it enough to reread it at least two or three times in the last 20 years since it was published in 2000. Spindle's End starts out much like the traditional fairy tale: An evil fairy, Pernicia (nice name!) places a fatal curse on the baby princess at her outdoor christening party, where all the kingdom has been invited to watch. But at that party is a young woman with the magical power of speaking to animals, Katriona. The royal magician, desperate for a way to evade the curse, hands over baby Rosie (she's got about fifteen official names, but Rosie is the one we'll go with) to Katriona, asking Katriona to keep the princess well hidden until after her 16th birthday. So totally-unprepared Katriona lugs baby Rosie all the way home to her village in the north part of the kingdom. It's a walking journey, one that takes several weeks, and Katriona has a hungry nursing infant on her hands. The wild animals of the kingdom pass the word along and start turning up each day to nurse baby Rose. It's really a delightful and unusual addition to the story. Rosie grows up with Katriona and her aunt, seemingly an ordinary village girl, and a more plain-spoken, unorthodox princess cannot be imagined. (Another delightful twist is how all of the other fairies' princess-appropriate gifts are subverted by Rosie's true nature.) But Rosie, Katriona and Katriona's aunt can all feel Pernicia's magic seeking to hunt down Rosie, and it only gets scarier as her sixteenth birthday approaches. Spindle's End isn't for everyone. Robin McKinley loves animals, and they play a major and unquestionably charming role in the story here, but McKinley also loves quirky and folksy details and speaking in digressions and parentheticals, and she takes her sweet time telling this story. There's one of those weird nightmarish scenes toward the end that McKinley is inexplicably fond of, when the characters get pulled into Pernicia's kingdom. And I'll just say that the final twist also will not be to everyone's taste. I'm not entirely sure it was for me, but as I've revisited Spindle's End a couple of times over the years I find myself more inclined to go along with McKinley's slow-paced but lovely reimagining of this story. Give it a shot if you're fond of fairy tale retellings, but be prepared to immerse yourself in a leisurely-told story with an abundance of additional details and a few odd twists.

Review # 2 was written on 2008-07-16 00:00:00 Bobby Maglaughlin Spindle's End (a retelling of Sleeping Beauty) is odd in a lot of respects, and therefore a lot of people aren't going to like it. To outline these: 1. Most of the book is narration. There is very little in the way of dialogue, even when it comes to things that most other authors would have left for characters to say. 2. It is hard to say who the main character really is. The person who you would assume to be the central character at the beginning is very peripheral by the end. 3. While based on a fairy tale, the resolution of the novel seems to be anything but formulaic. Even by regular fantasy novel standards, a lot of this comes out of left field. 4. It takes a very long time for things to happen (in the sense of action), and when it does you may miss it if you aren't paying attention. 5. Random facts about places, people, and customs of the fictional kingdom are dropped in sporadically. This adds a great deal of richness to the book, as well as causing a bit of confusion (some tidbits about customs, for instance, are dropped chapters before they are explained). All of that said, I really liked this book. The narration that makes it so odd is engaging enough to make up for the fact that you can go for pages without a character saying something. The descriptions were some of the best I've read in ages from any genre, and I was so happy that the novel ended in a way you would not guess from the start (one aspect of the ending was a given, but otherwise...completely offside). Overall, I would recommend this to a lot of people...with a big caveat regarding the narration. If you need a lot of things to happen very quickly, and a ton of witty banter from your characters, you may want to skip this one.