Reviews for Alistair Cooke's America

The average rating for Alistair Cooke's America based on 2 reviews is 4.5 stars.

Review # 1 was written on 2009-05-27 00:00:00 William Van Dyke A little dated and by nature not as deep as it could be, but it is a sympathetic third party look at American history by an Englishman who knew us well. The writing style is very user-friendly especially for those who are not history wonks. I think it could be the basis of a good high school American history course. I've re-read this book countless times since I rescued a copy from the recycling bin while in high school.

Review # 2 was written on 2018-10-15 00:00:00 Delphine Fekete ... a sign proclaiming in three words that a Roman emperor's orgy is now a democratic institution. It says: 'Topless Pizza Lunch.' (As in my reviews of Kenneth Clarke's Civilisation and Jacob Bronowski's The Ascent of Man, this review focuses on the documentary, not the tie-in book.) This documentary is a window into another time, when the public intellectual was a far more respected institution. Nowadays it is hard to imagine a popular program that contained long stretches of a man simply talking into a camera; nor it is easy to think of a contemporary program so fully dominated by the personality of one person. As the subtitle of this program indicates, this is "A Personal View," not an attempt at impartiality or objectivity. Cooke is giving us America as he sees it, through the eyes of a highly-educated, well-traveled English immigrant. The 13 episodes of the series follow a chronological scheme, beginning with the French and Spanish colonists and ending with the (then) present day. The exception to this is the first episode, the best in the series, in which Cooke tells his own story'coming to America as a young man during the Great Depression, and taking a road trip out west. As for the other episodes, there are few surprises in Cooke's choice of subject: the English dissenters, the Revolutionary War, the drafting of the Constitution, the Louisiana Purchase, and so on, all the way up to the Cold War. We see Ellis Island and the Oregon Trail, New England foliage and the Hoover Dam, Hippie communes and Black Baptist churches'a panorama of American scenes. In many ways this series falls short of the other two major BBC documentaries of the time, Clarke's Civilisation and Bronowski's The Ascent of Man. Cooke's America has none of the gorgeous cinematography of the former nor the innovative editing of the latter. Indeed, the shooting style of the documentary is remarkably basic'which is not necessarily a bad thing, of course, but in this case it imbued sections of the documentary with a soporific effect. Another difference in quality was due to the level of insight that the programs offer. Cooke, though no chump when it comes to American history, seems an amateur when his expertise is compared to Clarke's grasp of art and Bronowski's understanding of science. I was consistently interested, but I cannot say I came away from the program with any deep sense of insight into my vast homeland. All this being said, there are some delightful sections in the program. Cooke has a great knack for finding fascinating props. He holds up a vial containing tea preserved from the Boston Tea Party, or he holds the manuscript of Dickens's A Christmas Carol in the Morgan Library, or he itemizes the typical equipment and supplies taken by families on the Oregon Trail. And if the information he presents is not exactly striking, his easy eloquence and gentle wit give his facts a pleasing ring. Cooke's voice'with his faultless Transatlantic accent'was made for broadcasting, and transmits a sense of confident sophistication that is entirely rare today. Most valuable for us is Cooke's convincing sense of being above partisan politics'an intelligent observer unbound by any tribe. Again, could any similar program exist today?