Reviews for Hidden History: Exploring Our Secret Past

The average rating for Hidden History: Exploring Our Secret Past based on 2 reviews is 4.5 stars.

Review # 1 was written on 2009-02-12 00:00:00 Michael Cook Daniel Boorstein, former Librarian of Congress, (but not a librarian much to the consternation of many of my overly-credential-conscious-and picayune-librarian colleagues) is a wonderful writer and historian (his series entitled The Americans: The Americans The Colonial Experience,The Americans The Democratic Experience,The Americans The National Experience is masterful social history.)This book is collection of essays. In one essay ("A Wrestler With the Angel") he explores some of the pitfalls common to historical research. For example his "Law of the Survival of the Unread" states that very popular works, purchased and read widely may not survive, i.e. they are worn out or stolen from libraries, etc. Another law is "Survival of the durable/monumental. Religions have traditionally placed value on monumental objects: tombs, statues, temples, burial rituals, etc. Thus many religious objects survive which may give excessive prominence to religion in the particular culture under study. Color and odor are obviously lost. We now know that the Parthenon was actually painted in very garish colors, vastly different from the weathered marble were accustomed to seeing. We can often get a perverted view by what is saved. For example, the New England primer was used all over New England to teach students. There were so many copies, no one gave a thought to saving them. Sermons on the other hand, had almost no demand so there are multiple copies still extant. So which was the more influential? The controversy over Michelangelo's Sistine Chapel is another example of how our perception of an era may be influenced by what we currently see. The use of perfumes during the middle ages was not just a luxury but a necessity to cover up the gross stench of people who never took baths. Other "laws" include "Survival of the Protected and Collected" (government files which may or may not reveal the truth of a matter,) "Survival of materials Surrounding Controversies," (disputations and matters of controversy are always recorded, yet ordinary currents of daily life which flow smoothly may never be chronicled; our history of sexual mores is basically a history of deviance rather than normality, i and "Survival of the Academically Classifiable and Dignified" which states that the inherent conservatism of academics is to study the "classics," i.e.teach what they have been taught. Finally, "Survival of the Victorious Point of View" (rather obvious, rarely do we read about unsuccessful inventions) and "Survival of the Self-Serving;" what is written down may be what the politicians want history to believe reflecting their personal agendas.

Review # 2 was written on 2019-12-08 00:00:00 Kirsten Le Guerneuve While this book is getting on in years, the message remains true - the history we know is often the history we are told. There are many elements - from "pseudo-events" to unknown connections - that influence and impact the history we know and generally study. The book provides a unique perspective on the American experience through those stories and events that may be less familiar. A good read.