Reviews for The book of lost tales

The average rating for The book of lost tales based on 2 reviews is 3.5 stars.

Review # 1 was written on 2015-11-12 00:00:00 Zain Raza The Book of Lost Tales, Part Two (The History of Middle-Earth #2), J.R.R. Tolkien, Christopher Tolkien (Editor) The Book of Lost Tales is a collection of early stories by English writer J. R. R. Tolkien, published as the first two volumes of Christopher Tolkien's 12-volume series The History of Middle-earth, in which he presents and analyzes the manuscripts of those stories, which were the earliest form of the complex fictional myths that would eventually comprise The Silmarillion. Each of the Tales is followed by notes and a detailed commentary by Christopher Tolkien. For publication the book was split into two volumes: The Book of Lost Tales 1 (1983) and The Book of Lost Tales 2 (1984), but this is simply an editorial division. Both volumes are separated into several "Lost Tales". This is the second part of the Book of the Lost Tales of Elfinesse which Eriol the Mariner learned from the Elves of Tol Eressëa, the Lonely Isle in the western ocean, and afterwards wrote in the Golden Book of Tavrobel. Herein are told the Tales of Beren and Tinúviel, of the Fall of Gondolin and the Necklace of the Dwarves. Book 2: The Tale of Tinúviel 'first version of the tale of Beren and Lúthien Turambar and the Foalókë 'first version of the Túrin saga The Fall of Gondolin 'the only full narrative of the Fall of Gondolin The Nauglafring ' tale of the Dwarven necklace known as the Nauglamír The Tale of Eärendel 'the only full narrative of Eärendil's travels The History of Eriol or Ælfwine and the End of the Tales'an essay about the changes in the framework, and the "unwritten" tales. تاریخ نخستین خوانش: روز بیست و ششم ماه فوریه سال 2010 میلادی عنوان: داستانهای فراموش شده (قسمت دوم)؛ نویسنده: جی.آر.آر. تالکین؛ ادیتور: کریستوفر تالکین؛ دومین جلد از سری «تاریخ سرزمین میانه»، که نخستین بار: در ماه آگوست سال 1984 میلادی، در انگلستان، و در ماه نوامبر سال 1984 میلادی، در آمریکا، به چاپ رسید، عنوان جلد دوم سری «تاریخ سرزمین میانه»، با عنوان: «داستانهای فراموش شده (قسمت دوم)» نام دارد، و همانند کتاب نخستین از این سری، شامل نسخه های نخستین بخشهای گوناگون داستانهای منتشر شده ی «تالکین»: افسانه ها، و اسطوره های دوران اول است، که حتی برخی از آنها، نسخه های بسیار ویژه، و یکتایی هستند. پس از هر داستان، یک نقد، در قالب یک مقاله ی کوتاه، با قلم: «کریستوفر تالکین»، پسر «جی. آر. آر. تالکین»، به همراه اشعار، توضیحاتی در مورد نامها، و نحوه ی تلفظ، و نکات مهم دیگری در مورد آن داستان، برای خوانشگران پیدا و آشکار میشود. ا. شربیانی

Review # 2 was written on 2012-11-02 00:00:00 Elizabeth Boyle In the Book of Lost Tales, volumes 1 and 2, we have a more or less full picture of the earliest work Tolkien did in the development of his personal mythology that was to grow into the tales of Middle Earth. It was a mythology meant to provide his country England with something he felt it sorely needed, a foundation myth, and it was a vehicle which allowed him to explore and expand upon his own fascination with the world and stories of Faery and his love for the invented languages of his youth. The frame of the entire mythology at this point centred on the character of an English mariner (initially called Eriol and later Aelfwine each with varying origin stories) who was shipwrecked upon the isle of Tol Eressëa, the last bastion of the Elves who have all but fled the mortal world. Here are recounted to him the 'lost tales' of the Elves from prior to their departure from the wider world of men. While it always remained the case that Tolkien envisioned his Middle-Earth stories to be tales about the earliest, unknown histories of our own world as opposed to stories set on some completely alien fantasy world, the two Book of Lost Tales volumes really point out just how strongly Tolkien initially envisioned this link to be. In the first volume we were presented with some of the more cosmogonic myths: stories of the Valar and the creation of the world, the creation of the two Trees of Valinor and the Silmarils, the creation of the sun and moon, and the ultimate exile of the Elves from Valinor to the wider world. In the second volume things get a little closer to the ground as we hear tales of heroes and their deeds in their attempt to fight against the forces of Melko who would overthrow all that is good and beautiful in the world. I have to admit that volume 2 had a bumpy start for me with the Tales of Beren & Tinúviel and Turambar & the Foalókë being distinctly inferior to what they were to become in their fuller, more developed forms. In Beren and Luthien two things stood out as road blocks to my enjoyment: Beren as first envisioned was actually an elf of the Noldor and to me this robs the tale of his love of the immortal Tinúviel of much of its tragic grandeur, though it must be admitted that some does still remain; added to that was the fact that Melko's lieutenant in the tale, and the main opponent to the heroes, was not Sauron of the Ainur and lord of the isle of werewolves, but Tevildo Prince of Cats! It might just be me, but a giant house cat (no matter how large and mean) is a slightly less intriguing villain than one of the greatest of the gods. As I noted in my review of book 1, Tolkien was still working within a model that was much more based on traditional 'fairy tales' than what his stories of the First Age of Middle-Earth were to become so this element isn't exactly unexpected, just not my particular cuppa. As to Turambar, there wasn't anything specific I could point to as the deciding factor in my relative lack of enthusiasm, but having read what this tale was to become it certainly pales in comparison. For me that can pretty much sum up the points at which I was disappointed in both volumes: these are much paler, thinner, and in some ways shadowy versions of the tales I know. That being said, they have the virtue of being able to show me just how much the constant work and revision, the lifetime of unceasing development, love and thought that went into them truly turned what were inspired, but limited stories into things that truly were comparable to the mythic workings of a people. The depth and reality of the tales of Middle-Earth all started here with something much smaller and simpler, but which would prove to be the seeds of something so much greater. The layers that one can see were built upon these first canvasses give a fascinating glimpse into a creative process that was truly monumental. So on to what I did like in this volume: the tale of the Fall of Gondolin was almost all I could have hoped for. While I still weep at the unrealized potential of the rewrite to this story that Tolkien had started but abandoned far too early as presented in Unfinished Tales of Númenor and Middle-Earth, I at least was able to see the story of Tuor and his flight to the doomed city of Gondolin just as it is about to be overcome by the forces of Melko in a complete, and I must say rather satisfying, version. Tied in with this is the story of the Nauglafring, or the necklace of the Dwarves, which in itself is a rousingly Germanic tale of greed, curses, and doom that also allows for two of the great love stories of Tolkien's mythology to this point (that of Beren and Tinúviel on the one hand and of Tuor and Idril on the other) to dovetail into each other and become the genesis for the tale of Eärendel which was in many ways the very heart of Tolkien's mythology from the beginning. Eärendel himself was the child of Tuor and Idril who falls in love with Beren & Tinúviel's granddaughter Elwing and whose great mission is to be the only mariner able to sail to the land of Valinor. Interestingly in some early versions of the tale as presented here Eärendel is sometimes either unable to make his way to Valinor or finds that his journey there proved unnecessary and ultimately this is another case where Tolkien's later development of the tale proved to be more satisfying than what we initially find, but it is still an intriguing (and more importantly a fuller) glimpse into what would otherwise be little more than some bare bones references in later works. The final chapter of the volume is made up of scattered notes and poems that relate explicitly to the frame narrative and the life story of the mariner Eriol/Aelfwine. To me the greatest value these fragments hold is in showing how strongly Tolkien initially wanted to tie in his tales of Faery with the history of our own world (and specifically with England). I myself don't worry too much about this aspect of Tolkien's work, but it was obviously hugely important to him. Even in the later development of the tales of Middle-Earth which seem rather distant from any kind of mythological history of England we can see that the 'historical' element remains: specifically in the frame narrative of the 'Red Book of Westmarch' which lies as the pseudo-historical source of all of the published tales of Tolkien. All in all while a bit uneven, this book gave some intriguing glimpses into Tolkien's art, especially in places where a later development of a given tale was either never done or where what does exist is only fragmentary. Definitely something of primary interest to the Tolkien aficionado.