Reviews for Am I thin enough yet?

The average rating for Am I thin enough yet? based on 2 reviews is 4 stars.

Review # 1 was written on 2008-07-09 00:00:00 Kristina Kourounis Why I liked it in one sentence: The Cult of Thinness shifts the focus of disordered eating from the individual or family unit to the dominant culture we live in- - steeped in a false mind/body dichotomy, rampant capitalism, and impossible/ destructive gender ideals. Why it didn't get 5 stars: Didn't really tell me anything I didn't already know, and most of the author's research focused on white middle class undergrads (surprise, surprise), so was somewhat limited in scope. Bottom line: Worth reading, but don't buy it--pick it up from your library. Caveat: Just reading this stirred up some of my old feelings of body-anxiety. If you are in recovery from an eating or body-image disorder, I'd recommend making sure you are in a pretty good place with all that before picking up this book.

Review # 2 was written on 2013-02-13 00:00:00 Jason SANDERS It was an okay book. I discovered it in a humanities class when it was on the reading list. I took it out from the library to read again. It affected me on a personal level. So many things in the book I could relate to. I liked this book because it wasn't just about eating disorders; it was about the context surrounding the drive to be thin, and proposed the notion of a culture, or a "cult of thinness". I wished the book did more. Like someone said before, there was nothing in the book that I didn't really know before. But the bigger question I wished was answered was, "Why?" Why are girls dying to be thin, even they know they're hurting themselves, even though they know about the social-historical context surrounding women's bodies. Why do they keep playing into it? Why do I keep playing into it? My Review of the book two years later: The author has done extensive research, and that is commendable. Statements are supported by statistics and research studies and interviews, and references are really thorough at the end of each chapter. So I applaud Hesse-Biber's tireless research that went into this book. This is the second time I've read the book. I was both shocked and apathetic. The sheer amount of statistics made me apathetic. It was like, after a while I got so bored of reading the same sort of thing reiterated over and over again. I was shocked that there are teachers out there who truly believe that chubby girls are stupid. But when I thought about it again, it suddenly twigged. When I was a girl in primary school, teachers riffed off of my weight. Of course students did it, but you kind of expected that when you were chubby. Kids can be cruel. But when teachers did it, it had more of an impact. In grade 11 Physics, my friend was feeling bad about her weight (we had to use our own weights in the experimental calculations). Anyhow, my physics teacher, who was really slender, tall, svelte, told my friend not to feel bad, because she had a lot of "bulk", and she tried to put a positive spin on it. That she would want someone with a lot of "bulk" on her volleyball team. This was a teacher that my friend highly respected. I was 16 then, and my teacher was God, and I never thought to question this interaction until years later. How could she publicly comment on a teenage girl's weight/body type? She didn't do it to be mean. She honestly though there was nothing wrong with what she said. The Culture of Thinness is insidious. It permeates our culture, ourselves, entirely. It explains why America is obsessed with a certain body type, why culturally-induced eating disorders emerge, why America's obesity epidemic is surging, why fad diets are so popular, and the entire industry that is built on yo-yo dieting. It creates this: It creates a circle where those who fit the ideal body type get to stay inside the circle, and everyone else is cast outside. The entire body industry (fad diets, weight loss supplements, magazines, new exercise equipment, good foods vs. bad foods), is based on the attempts for those outside the circle to find their way back in. And most of them can't, thus explaining yo-yo dieting. If Hesse-Biber ever decides to write a third edition, I hope she will expand the chapter on lesbians/gays, straight men, and racial minorities. Hesse-Biber is, herself, from a position of privilege. I would like to see her expand the chapter by conducting extensive interviews with a large sample size of black women, for example. I fear that many of the things she has said are common assumptions. For example, I've read that women of colour suffer from body image issues perhaps even more than white women, due to the social variables of race and maybe economic class. This book is excellent from the viewpoint of white women, but I would like to see more diverse representation in terms of the research especially. In 2013, I gave this book 3 stars. In 2015, I am giving this book 4 stars. This book is fantastic, but there is so much work to be done, in terms of exploring the culture of (whiteness) and thinness.