Wonder Club world wonders pyramid logo
×

Reviews for In Fact: The Best of Creative Nonfiction

 In Fact magazine reviews

The average rating for In Fact: The Best of Creative Nonfiction based on 29 reviews is 3.8620689655172 stars.has a rating of 3.8620689655172 stars

Review # 1 was written on 2017-05-09 00:00:00
2004was given a rating of 4 stars Nicholas Tubb
After recently reading In Short: A Collection of Brief Creative Nonfiction, I checked the the library on the campus where I work to see what other collections of creative nonfiction they had.. In Short was fine, but the essays were "brief creative nonfiction", and I wanted to find something that had more complete and full essays. This was the first to pop up.

I have read some reviews by people who clearly don't understand what this is. So let me, briefly, explain it to others so if you pick this After recently reading In Short: A Collection of Brief Creative Nonfiction, I checked the the library on the campus where I work to see what other collections of creative nonfiction they had.. In Short was fine, but the essays were "brief creative nonfiction", and I wanted to find something that had more complete and full essays. This was the first to pop up.

I have read some reviews by people who clearly don't understand what this is. So let me, briefly, explain it to others so if you pick this up you don't make the same embarrassing pronouncements that other reviewers have. The title, In Fact: The Best of Creative Nonfiction, refers to the literary magazine founded by Lee Gutkind, the editor of this collection. The name of the magazine is Creative Nonfiction. The "Best" in the subtitle indicates that this collection comprises the best submissions the magazine has received.

This is not a book claiming that these are the BEST creative nonfiction essays OF ALL TIME.

For crying out loud, people.

It's silly to complain that this collection has no cohesion, no main theme, or whatever else people are saying. These are the best submissions the magazine has received over the years, so there's a wide variety of writing. They're not all memoir, though most of them have components of memoir. This does not mean the collection lacks depth or diversity. The essays are all vastly different in style, tone, and theme.

As in any collection, some essays will be better than others. There are a lot of familiar names to many readers in this collection (John Edgar Wideman, John McPhee, Charles Simic, Ntozake Shange, Diane Ackerman, Andrei Codrescu, and Francine Prose to name a few), and others are new to me because I am always learning: Lauren Slater, Ruthann Robson, Floyd Skloot, Jewell Parker Rhodes, or Jana Richman.

I read this over the course of about nine days, primarily on the bus to and from work. Most of the essays are short enough to read in one or two sittings, and others are short enough to read over a lunch break. There's a brief biography at the beginning of each essay so the reader learns a little something about each one before really delving in. At the end of each essay, though, is where the real magic happens. That's where the author would write a few paragraphs or a few pages (in some cases) about the impetus for the writing of the essay the reader just read, and a little blurby-blurb with advice for writers.

I love shit like that. Give me the advice, all of the advice. Tell me what you've gone through, tell me which pitfalls I will undoubtedly experience, tell me not to quit my day job. I love it all, bring it on.

This is a great collection overall. I won't go through and count the number of essays I enjoyed or didn't enjoy to come up with some sort of mathematical average. I'm going with my heart on this one.

If you're also interested in reading or writing creative nonfiction, this is a good place to start. You can read a variety of authors (from a variety of backgrounds and experiences) share their stories, you can study their craft, and you can just soak up their advice on writing.

Also, the introduction by Annie Dillard is spot-on. She's the reason I decided to apply to an MFA with a concentration in creative nonfiction. If I don't get accepted, it won't be Annie's fault. She's just a bad-ass that we should all aspire to be.
Review # 2 was written on 2007-07-09 00:00:00
2004was given a rating of 5 stars Anetra Nabozna
First, note that the title is a bit misleading. It is not an attempt to be the best of creative nonfiction as a genre, but of the literary journal "Creative Nonfiction." That said, this is a wonderful collection of essays ranging from the highly personal to the journalistic. Of the pieces in the book, I learn toward the more personal selections (" Leaving Babylon," "Shunned," "Three Spheres") and those that most effectively bridge the personal/journalistic gap ("Emmit Till"). Though the essays l First, note that the title is a bit misleading. It is not an attempt to be the best of creative nonfiction as a genre, but of the literary journal "Creative Nonfiction." That said, this is a wonderful collection of essays ranging from the highly personal to the journalistic. Of the pieces in the book, I learn toward the more personal selections (" Leaving Babylon," "Shunned," "Three Spheres") and those that most effectively bridge the personal/journalistic gap ("Emmit Till"). Though the essays listed above are my favorites, "Leaving Babylon" and "Shunned" are particuarly heartbreaking, every piece in the collection is engaging and well written.

As an added bonus, this collection is clear in its audience (the young non-fiction writer) and each essay ends with the author (in most cases) talking about the how and why of their piece and some advice to young writers. These themes are echoed from the introduction by Annie Dillard ("Advice to Young Writers") and Lee Guntkind ("Creative NonFiction Police").

An excellently edited and written collection that would be a valuable addition to a beginning writer's collection.
Review # 3 was written on 2015-07-05 00:00:00
2004was given a rating of 3 stars Amber Rizzo
This collection suffers from what I like to call Collectionitis, meaning that, as a collection, it suffers an identity crisis and an obscene, tiring variation in quality of the contents.
This book doesn't know what it wants to be- and even more troubling, doesn't know what it wants to present its subject (creative nonfiction) as. Some entries are memoir-like, others bland and forgettable essays, some trite examples of biography, and the requisite entries that I actually found myself enjoying. Seriously, though- a book of essays does not a collection of creative nonfiction make. The operative word here is CREATIVE, so the entries that were bland and lacking in their own emotional spin were usually the ones I found exasperating.

My favorites in the collection were Three Spheres, Shunned, Dinner at Uncle Boris's, killing wolves, Language at Play, and Delivering Lily, and it's worth mentioning that the introduction by Annie Dillard far surpasses the foreword by Lee Gutkind, which you're better off skipping.

Most of the stories were so-so, but there were a few that I couldn't stand (What Is It We Really Harvestin' Here, The Brown Study, Prayer Dogs, and Gray Area: Thinking with a Danaged Brain), some of which I couldn't muster up a modicum of interest to finish.

Another thing that I believe threw me out of the book is that the best story by far is the first one- Three Soheres- and raised my expectations, which quickly dropped through a decent first half, a few forgettable entries I was competent apathetic towards, and the plummeted during the completely bland second half. Basically, just skip this collection.
Review # 4 was written on 2016-08-02 00:00:00
2004was given a rating of 4 stars Dave Hybertson
Excellent book! Great creative nonfiction short stories. I am now reading Gutkind's book "You Can't Make This Stuff Up" and it is very useful for me because I am writing creative nonfiction. Excellent book! Great creative nonfiction short stories. I am now reading Gutkind's book "You Can't Make This Stuff Up" and it is very useful for me because I am writing creative nonfiction.
Review # 5 was written on 2014-04-27 00:00:00
2004was given a rating of 4 stars Christie Sposeto
Most people that know me understand that i have an obsession with the essay writing of Tom Wolfe and Hunter Thompson. I read nonfiction because i crave information but suffer when it is presented in a dry manner. From this collection I learned that the Orthodox Jews have a prayer, "Thank God I am not a woman". I had the opportunity to revisit race and the miscegenation of all people. I now know a little more about the resiliency of women as seen through the eyes of a woman of Mormon Heritage. I have the feeling that mothers teach their daughters more than they teach their sons and feel gipped about what i may have missed in childhood. While not as colorful as Wolfe or as bombast as Thompson, this collection is worthy of a reader's attention.
Review # 6 was written on 2014-04-09 00:00:00
2004was given a rating of 3 stars Tanya Estrada
A few gems in here, and great writing throughout, but as with all collections, some are gonna be more your bag than others. What makes this book a treat are the mini-essays at the end of each main essay, explaining a bit more about the impetus for writing the piece, along with some background of the writer's life. They feel a little like interviews where only the answers got published, maybe because each one features some piece of writerly advice to the novice writer.
Review # 7 was written on 2009-01-28 00:00:00
2004was given a rating of 4 stars Kenneth Calleros
I loved this collection of Creative Non-Fiction. I learned a lot, I laughed, I cried. I really appreciated how every author gave some little piece about their essay at the end, usually with some writing advice. If you get a chance to read it, Chimera is a must. I forget the guy that wrote it, but it's too good. I loved this collection of Creative Non-Fiction. I learned a lot, I laughed, I cried. I really appreciated how every author gave some little piece about their essay at the end, usually with some writing advice. If you get a chance to read it, Chimera is a must. I forget the guy that wrote it, but it's too good.
Review # 8 was written on 2018-10-01 00:00:00
2004was given a rating of 5 stars Bryan Shipman
I love Gutkind's edited collections. The essays in this one crackle with reality beautifully put. There's something about this genre that irks people, I think, judging by the number of editorial justifications for its existence (by both the editor and in short explanatory notes provided at the end of each essay, often by the author). No need. It takes great skill to render nonfiction as narrative in the way these authors do; they lay themselves bare and they do it with great poetry and honesty. I love Gutkind's edited collections. The essays in this one crackle with reality beautifully put. There's something about this genre that irks people, I think, judging by the number of editorial justifications for its existence (by both the editor and in short explanatory notes provided at the end of each essay, often by the author). No need. It takes great skill to render nonfiction as narrative in the way these authors do; they lay themselves bare and they do it with great poetry and honesty. Some of my favourites looked at the immune system as a vehicle for memory, a psychologist's experience returning to an institution where she used to be a patient, a teenager shunned when she becomes pregnant and then forced to give up her child, an animal-lover among wolf trappers...and really, most of the entire contents. It's a genre that puts people out there in the world, then harnesses those experiences to create insightful stories that are a great pleasure to read. Highly recommended.
Review # 9 was written on 2018-12-29 00:00:00
2004was given a rating of 4 stars Timothy Mcginn
In the last decade or so, creative nonfiction has emerged as a popular genre, with readers becoming more and more interested in personal stories that are just as well-crafted as their favorite novels. This collection represents a body of work that is masterful, inspiring, and a powerful representation of what essays can achieve when they're done right. Some standouts include "Delivering Lily" by Phillip Lopate, which is an unflinching look at the birth of his daughter; "In The Woods", Leslie Rub In the last decade or so, creative nonfiction has emerged as a popular genre, with readers becoming more and more interested in personal stories that are just as well-crafted as their favorite novels. This collection represents a body of work that is masterful, inspiring, and a powerful representation of what essays can achieve when they're done right. Some standouts include "Delivering Lily" by Phillip Lopate, which is an unflinching look at the birth of his daughter; "In The Woods", Leslie Rubinkowski's exploration of truth as it relates to family ties and family history; and "Notes from a Difficult Case", in which Ruthann Robson makes legal matters extremely personal. As a writer who works best in essay form, this collection serves as a North Star - one I'll visit again and again to get inspired by and aspire to.
Review # 10 was written on 2018-11-30 00:00:00
2004was given a rating of 4 stars Jacky Pearson
Great collection. There was one essay that I just couldn't read, just the style of writing I guess, was tedious. To me. What I like about good creative nonfiction is that it shouldn't matter what it's about, it draws you in. But it does have to be well written. I especially liked the Williams and the Simic. Great collection. There was one essay that I just couldn't read, just the style of writing I guess, was tedious. To me. What I like about good creative nonfiction is that it shouldn't matter what it's about, it draws you in. But it does have to be well written. I especially liked the Williams and the Simic.
Review # 11 was written on 2017-06-24 00:00:00
2004was given a rating of 5 stars Deborah Bowers
Some of the short stories definitely resonated with me more, but they were all beautifully written and deeply interesting. I keep this book in my locker at work so I can force it into the hands of as many people as possible.
Review # 12 was written on 2020-05-04 00:00:00
2004was given a rating of 5 stars Ken Smith
This is an excellent collection of creative nonfiction. The book starts out with some heavy content, so I would recommend jumping around a little bit. They don't need to be read in order. I think this might be my new favorite genre. This is an excellent collection of creative nonfiction. The book starts out with some heavy content, so I would recommend jumping around a little bit. They don't need to be read in order. I think this might be my new favorite genre.
Review # 13 was written on 2019-06-25 00:00:00
2004was given a rating of 5 stars Lori Simms
Great read for an aspiring creative nonfiction writer. I have half of the book highlighted.
Review # 14 was written on 2020-01-07 00:00:00
2004was given a rating of 1 stars Walter Cordova
I read "Shunned" by Meredith Hall.
Review # 15 was written on 2020-10-27 00:00:00
2004was given a rating of 4 stars Hazem Fouad
A little uneven, but generally some pretty good reading.
Review # 16 was written on 2011-08-06 00:00:00
2004was given a rating of 4 stars Alexander Drinda
What a feast! Quotes and snippets from the essays:

Creative nonfiction is "what we call the literature of reality..." (Lee Gutkind)

No laws govern the scope of good taste and personal integrity. (Gutkind)

Lauren Slater, speaking as a psychotherapist: "... I'm supposedly in a profession that values honesty and self-revelation."

Loneliness is an old story which belongs to all of us. (Meredith Hall)

John McPhee quoting an elderly woman's description of a teacher in her diary: "... a square prunes-and-prisms lady with a mouth like a buttonhole."

McPhee, on looking for a certain book in an open-stacks library: "The book you knew about has led you to others you did not know about. To the ceiling the shelves are loaded with books about Nevada [his subject of research at the time]. You pull them down, one at at time, and sit on the floor and look them over until you are sitting on a pile five feet high ..." (and have several more high piles hemming you in ... Bliss!)

McPhee: "It has been alleged [by his mother] that when I was in college she heard that I had stayed up all night playing poker and [she] wrote me a letter that used the word 'shame' forty-two times. I do not recall this."

Charles Simic, describing one of his uncles at a family dinner: "My Uncle Boris would make Mother Teresa reach for a baseball bat." On his brother and father, also at the dinner, who tell Charles (the family rationalist) that his attempts at logical argument don't measure up: "... my brother interrupts to tell me that I'm full of shit. His philosophy is: The more reasonable it sounds, the less likely it is that it's true. My father, on the other hand, always takes the Olympian view. 'None of you know what the fuck you're talking about,' he informs us, and resumes slurping his soup."

Richard Rodriguez, on the air in L.A.: "... on many days, the air turns fuscous from the scent glands of planes and from Lexus musk."

"A trapper tells me, 'Fur is organic. It doesn't ruin one thing in the woods to use it.' Except the animal itself, of course." (Sherry Simpson)

Judyth Har-Even, on her Orthodox Jewish divorce: "Whereas God was present in my wedding ceremony, He is absent from the divorce proceedings. His name is neither mentioned nor invoked. I imagine Him off in a corner, sulking, and for good reason. What, after all, has God been doing every day since the creation of the world? According to the Babylonian Talmud, He has been running a dating service, matchmaking, a task more difficult, the sages claim, than splitting the waters during the Exodus."

Leslie Rubinkowski describes her teenaged self as having "a head full of adolescent disco misery ..."

Rubinowski, on her beloved grandfather: "In his mind he was the guy who rescued naked women in the woods, resourceful and dashing even without teeth, a coal-patch Cary Grant."

Floyd Skloot's essay, "Gray Area: Thinking with a Damaged Brain", is a smart, compassionate gem for anyone who's experienced an injury or illness of the brain. His first line is, "I used to be able to think." What a paradox! -- or so it seems. The rest of piece tells in intricate detail of what "I used to be able think" means to the author. Even so, he's a world-class author of essays, fiction, and poetry. I salute him.
Other essayists include Annie Dillard, John Edgar Wideman, Philip Lopate, Francine Prose and Terry Tempest Williams ... and there are two more books in the series! :-)
Review # 17 was written on 2011-08-27 00:00:00
2004was given a rating of 3 stars Brian Meadows
For a school book, this was really good. I must admit I was not looking forward to reading it after hearing some unfavorable reviews, but I found it fairly easy to read and most of the essays were enjoyable.

This is a collection of essays and excerpts from books written in the "creative nonfiction" genre. The entire collection features reflections and suggestions about the genre; the introduction explains how the genre is a very popular crossover between fact and fiction. Like storytelling or memoirs, authors write about their own lives or the lives of others in a way that is true yet reads like a novel. Yet it is clear that this is only one truth, because it is purposefully personal and not objective. I realized that this is the genre into which The Immortal Life of Henrietta Lacks falls, and it gives me the words I've been searching for since I read it.

So, being an anthology, some pieces are better than others. There are some that are very personal and serious memoirs, yet completely compelling and captured my attention ("Three Spheres," "Shunned," and "Notes from a Difficult Case," for example). There are a few that lacked a distinct story line, yet were fascinating and interesting reflections ("Being Brians" was one of my favorite, being humorous; "Chimera" and "Gray Area: Thinking with a Damaged Brain" were more serious ones). Then there were those that I didn't enjoy, either because they were too long ("Sa'm Pedi"), un-relatable ("Looking at Emmett Till"), or just a confusing, rambling jumble ("An Album Quilt"). (Sorry.) At the end of each story, the author reflects on writing his or her essay and gives advice for budding writers. I liked reading all of these conclusions, because it really gave life to the essay, letting me inside the writer's head as they described their struggles. Most ended up adding material to their essays by accident, but found that it became the piece's defining trait; some went through the ordeal of reliving painful experiences. This helped me connect the writing to a living human being, rather than having the author be some abstract being whose words I labor to interpret. It's creative nonfiction; it's real.

In conclusion, future seniors should not be afraid of this book.
Review # 18 was written on 2009-08-23 00:00:00
2004was given a rating of 3 stars Ronald Bondy
As with almost any collection of work by various authors, "In Fact" is rather uneven. There were a few great stories, a few terrible ones, but mostly they were in-between.

I think my biggest complaint is really a differing idea of what creative non-fiction is. Gutkind's choices include too many stories that, to me, are more memoir than anything else, but when I think of creative non-fiction I tend to think of non-fiction pieces on a particular subject, like homesteading (Jonathan Raban's "Bad Lan As with almost any collection of work by various authors, "In Fact" is rather uneven. There were a few great stories, a few terrible ones, but mostly they were in-between.

I think my biggest complaint is really a differing idea of what creative non-fiction is. Gutkind's choices include too many stories that, to me, are more memoir than anything else, but when I think of creative non-fiction I tend to think of non-fiction pieces on a particular subject, like homesteading (Jonathan Raban's "Bad Land") or medical anthropology (Anne Fadiman's "The Spirit Catches You and You Fall Down") that are recounted creatively and with the author's own emotions and experiences included as part of the story.

Annie Dillard's introduction is humorous, practical, and (to aspiring writers) hope-giving -- and frankly, more worthwhile than Lee Gutkind's foreword.

Some of my very favorite of the stories are, in order of appearance:
Killing Wolves, Sherry Simpson
Being Bryans, Bryan Doyle
Gray Area, Floyd Skloot
Sa'm Pèdi, Madison Smartt Bell

It's also worth noting that either Gutkind or Ntozake Shange (author: "What We Really Harvestin' Here?") made a glaring mistake. Shange's bibliographical blurb gives the meaning of her name "in Xhosa, the Zulu language," but Xhosa isn't the Zulu language -- Zulu is. The Xhosa and the Zulu are two very different ethnic groups that both happen to live in South Africa.

I finished every story in the book except for one, Robert Rodriguez's (purposefully) purple and opaque "Brown Study," which is worth skipping.
Review # 19 was written on 2019-02-10 00:00:00
2004was given a rating of 5 stars Dave Fawns
I love teaching CNF from this book!
Review # 20 was written on 2011-05-20 00:00:00
2004was given a rating of 4 stars Nicholas Phariss
"In Fact" was a phenomenal collection of creative nonfiction pieces, but my favorite essay had to be "Shunned" by Meredith Hall. In "Shunned" Meredith is sixteen and pregnant in 1965 New Hampshire, living in a small, close-knit community that ostracizes her after hearing of her condition. Her description of what it is like being a pregnant teenager was heartbreaking and really opened my eyes to teenage pregnancy, and also to the fact that people can and will treat you differently as soon as you do something against the social norm.

This essay discussed many important themes, such as teenage pregnancy, how quickly a community can turn its back, being left behind, and the pressures, expectations, and requirements of 1960's American society.
There were also several supporting characters, including Meredith's mother, who asks her to leave the house and live with her father, and her father, who doesn't let her go outside while she is pregnant and lives with him and his new wife.

The only thing I disliked about the story "Shunned" was the fact that it made me remember events in my own life, such as being left behind by an old school with my old friends whom I had been with since kindergarten. But, I suppose, such is life.

I enjoyed how this book was geared towards young writers. Each essay is ended with a note from the author explaining more about the writing style, process, etc., and the book is started off with a message to young authors.
Review # 21 was written on 2007-08-13 00:00:00
2004was given a rating of 3 stars Brad Taylor
I finished this books weeks agos, and to its credit I continue to refer to it in conversation. I have two major criticisms for this volume. First, the sheer length is daunting--I felt hijacked halfway through it. I don't usually read more than one book at a time and I couldn't move through this dense thicket of essays with any speed. Additionally, it's poorly organized. I wasn't sure why the essays were in their particular order. And each essay has a distracting bio of the author on the first pa I finished this books weeks agos, and to its credit I continue to refer to it in conversation. I have two major criticisms for this volume. First, the sheer length is daunting--I felt hijacked halfway through it. I don't usually read more than one book at a time and I couldn't move through this dense thicket of essays with any speed. Additionally, it's poorly organized. I wasn't sure why the essays were in their particular order. And each essay has a distracting bio of the author on the first page so that just as you're absorbing the opening line of an author's hard-fought essay, the line organization of the page tosses you into a not-that-well-written bio. These are both petty annoyances, I admit. If you love essays, I do recommend _In Fact_. Lots of good reading. Annie Dillard's intro is so good that I literally had to set the book down when I was finished reading it. Floyd Skloot's "Thinking With a Damaged Brain" and Philip Gerard's "Delivering Lily" were also mind twisting they were so well written. "Thinking" totally changed my perception of brain injuries and "Lily" should be required reading for all fathers-to-be.
Review # 22 was written on 2011-06-19 00:00:00
2004was given a rating of 3 stars Joshua Stimpson
It seems a shame to give this thick book just three stars, given the number of essays I really liked. However, several were just so-so, and there were a few ("What Is It We Really Harvestin' Here?", "The Brown Study," and "Adventures in Celestial Navigation") that I simply gave up on. More than it succeeds in capturing the "best" of the creative non-fiction genre, this book manages to encompass the genre's variety. It seems inevitable that no reader will be completely satisfied. For the most part, though, I enjoyed what I read. A few essays("Shunned," "Joe Stopped By," and "Delivering Lily") truly absorbed me. Best of all (but also one of the most frustrating) was the fascinating account of Joey Coyle, an unemployed drug addict in South Philly who stumbled across a huge sum of money and then tried to devise a way to hold onto it without letting the authorities know where it was. I wanted to read a whole book devoted to this story; instead, I went on to read several more pieces that were far less riveting. Ultimately, then, I guess three stars is fair. This book is above average, but not by much.
Review # 23 was written on 2012-09-14 00:00:00
2004was given a rating of 3 stars Donald Dietrich
A moderately interesting read, "In fact: the Best of Creative Nonfiction" is an effective compilation of creative non-fiction shorts which teach the reader what the genre of creative non-fiction truly entails. While the novel does indeed contain *some* engaging stories, it is hard to get to these awesome stories because the book begins with a few mildly soporific creative non-fiction short's which prove rather discouraging for the reader who wishes to progress (or is required to finish) the book A moderately interesting read, "In fact: the Best of Creative Nonfiction" is an effective compilation of creative non-fiction shorts which teach the reader what the genre of creative non-fiction truly entails. While the novel does indeed contain *some* engaging stories, it is hard to get to these awesome stories because the book begins with a few mildly soporific creative non-fiction short's which prove rather discouraging for the reader who wishes to progress (or is required to finish) the book. Because of the stokes of genius within the book, and because of the good editing which enables a book of short-stories to create a well-developed picture of the genre of creative non-fiction (which is the intention of the compilation), Gutkind's book succeeds a teaching device suitable for the aspiring writing seeking to further or begin his/her understanding of creative nonfiction.
Review # 24 was written on 2009-02-18 00:00:00
2004was given a rating of 4 stars Mitchell Goossen
I enjoyed this very much. It's a collection of essays from the magazine "Creative Nonfiction." Some of them I skimmed or skipped, but many I found very interesting and even worthy of recommending to others.

Favorites were:

"Being Brians" by Brian Doyle - an essay about the many people sharing the name Brian Doyle.

"Leaving Babylon: A Walk Through the Jewish Divorce Ceremony" by Judyth Har-Even - a very interesting description and commentary by a modern woman in an ancient religion.

"Chimera" by Gera I enjoyed this very much. It's a collection of essays from the magazine "Creative Nonfiction." Some of them I skimmed or skipped, but many I found very interesting and even worthy of recommending to others.

Favorites were:

"Being Brians" by Brian Doyle - an essay about the many people sharing the name Brian Doyle.

"Leaving Babylon: A Walk Through the Jewish Divorce Ceremony" by Judyth Har-Even - a very interesting description and commentary by a modern woman in an ancient religion.

"Chimera" by Gerald N. Callahan - about that sense of seeing someone who is gone from our lives, and how memory may reside in us.

"Mixed-Blood Stew" by Jewell Parker Rhodes - about race and heritage.

Others were good, but these stood out for me. Very nice mix.
Review # 25 was written on 2015-07-09 00:00:00
2004was given a rating of 1 stars Ryan Straub
Almost the first thirty-five pages are written by the editor touting his bringing creative non-fiction to his college, as well as his writing about the classes he wrote, teaching his students to pad with plenty of description, especially when getting close to a climax. A read a few of the articles which Gutkind called the best of creative non-fiction. I did not enjoy them at all. After reading a few, I then did a short sampling, but by that time I was totally turned off.

If you get this book to read, skip all the intros and go to the first story. Maybe it will be better that way. In the meantime, I will try very hard to stay away from his work, unless it is highly recommended by someone whose judgment I trust. There is too much really good stuff to read to wade through this.
Review # 26 was written on 2012-11-03 00:00:00
2004was given a rating of 4 stars William Bright
This was an excellent collection. It reminds me of some of the better years of "Best American Essays," because I found myself reading one fascination piece after another. I particularly enjoyed: "Looking at Emmett Till," by John Edgar Wideman; "Shunned," by Meredith Hall; "What is it we really harvesting here," by Ntozake Shange; and "Leaving Babylon: a walk through the Jewish divorce ceremony," by Judyth Har-Even.

I'm late returning this book to the library, so one thing I have to do after writ This was an excellent collection. It reminds me of some of the better years of "Best American Essays," because I found myself reading one fascination piece after another. I particularly enjoyed: "Looking at Emmett Till," by John Edgar Wideman; "Shunned," by Meredith Hall; "What is it we really harvesting here," by Ntozake Shange; and "Leaving Babylon: a walk through the Jewish divorce ceremony," by Judyth Har-Even.

I'm late returning this book to the library, so one thing I have to do after writing this review is buy myself a copy online.
Review # 27 was written on 2018-12-15 00:00:00
2004was given a rating of 5 stars Don Parker
It includes everything from Dillard to McPhee and extrapolates on the journal that broke ground in creative territory: paving the way for literary nonfiction. Not only a showcase but a preclude of a genre that wouldn't have existed if not for a few stark editors on a hunt for particular essayists. Now there are so many creative nonfictionists, they could form a galaxy. Then, they didn't have a subgenre to call their own. Definitely worth the read but if you do, the introduction and preface are e It includes everything from Dillard to McPhee and extrapolates on the journal that broke ground in creative territory: paving the way for literary nonfiction. Not only a showcase but a preclude of a genre that wouldn't have existed if not for a few stark editors on a hunt for particular essayists. Now there are so many creative nonfictionists, they could form a galaxy. Then, they didn't have a subgenre to call their own. Definitely worth the read but if you do, the introduction and preface are essential to frame the context of CNF. Thank you L. Gutkind! The best nonfiction there is.
Review # 28 was written on 2010-09-16 00:00:00
2004was given a rating of 5 stars Ricardo Valentin Trejo Guzman
This collection of essays must be great writing, because some of the subjects would not usually hold my interest for very long. It's a great book to read and a great book if you write. The introduction is by Annie Dillard, and it's such good advice I seriously read it with my mouth open. There were a couple of duds, but most of the essays are brilliant, and the writers, too, discuss their thought/creative process after each piece.
Review # 29 was written on 2013-11-10 00:00:00
2004was given a rating of 5 stars James Rose
Lee Gutkind's collection of favorites was extremely inspiring for this amateur nonfiction reader. Starting out with this collection gave me insight on different voices, desires, motives, and real life situations. There is a story to inspire everyone in this collection; from the reader seeking truth about a relationship to finding answers within yourself. This is a book a will go back to again and again.


Click here to write your own review.


Login

  |  

Complaints

  |  

Blog

  |  

Games

  |  

Digital Media

  |  

Souls

  |  

Obituary

  |  

Contact Us

  |  

FAQ

CAN'T FIND WHAT YOU'RE LOOKING FOR? CLICK HERE!!!