Reviews for Young Adult Catholics: Religion in the Culture of Choice

The average rating for Young Adult Catholics: Religion in the Culture of Choice based on 2 reviews is 5 stars.

Review # 1 was written on 2018-11-22 00:00:00 Raven Nanie I had read this book a first time more than ten years ago and re-reading it recently, I re-discovered how these four thought-provoking essays were a challenge, sometimes a little bit irksome, sometimes even a little bit too direct, by Kevin Whelan to reconsider the historiography of the 1790s and to step out of our preconceptions in order to look at this crucial time for was it really was. In examining the place of Catholics and Catholicism in Ireland, and especially the "underground gentry" (which I had used in my memoir for my maîtrise) before and after the Rebellion, the United Irishmen politics and broad appeal to a Irish "nation" regardless of religious creed, in the conflict between the conservative United Irishmen and the radical ones as well as the historiography after '98, Whelan tackles down many of the bogus myths that were constructed after the Rebellion and which have obscured our understanding of what it meant exactly to rebel against the government, to rise up to defend -- to defend what? Well, in examining this issue, Whelan reminds us of how the post-'98 period was marked by Daniel O'Connell and how the "Liberator" has played the card of sectarianism and the past to define the Irish nation as catholic while the UI were non-sectarian and turned towards the future. If, sometimes, these essays are a little bit too demonstrative or provocative in the sense that one feels the need to read more carefully-built arguments to support some of the ideas, as, for instance, in the last one when Whelan argues that the propaganda orchestrated by the government about the sectarian nature of the rising in the south was responsible for the defection and turn-over of the Presbyterians to the forces of conservatism and counter-revolution in the north, none the less, they are really, really useful and indispensable to come out of our comfort (and, we discover, conservative-built) zone.

Review # 2 was written on 2018-11-22 00:00:00 Mark Gall The real question is, Is he REALLY a Post-revisionist?! Judging from his own criteria he sets forth in the introduction, I'd say not!