Reviews for Emerson and Self-Culture

The average rating for Emerson and Self-Culture based on 2 reviews is 4 stars.

Review # 1 was written on 2015-04-10 00:00:00 Michael Stephen Sanger A fine biography, full of color and energy, but not a particularly good intellectual biography. Muller peppers the text with unhelpful and often entirely misleading terms like "progressive" and "reactionary," and he judges every other Bryant poem to be "innovative" somehow. He also falls into the biographer's trap of making his subject the most important person ever, taking note of every hyperbolic statement Bryant's many admirers made to that effect. On the other hand, Muller does make a good case for Bryant's importance in American letters and politics, and he is largely effective in using Bryant's long life as a way to examine a changing society. Much more could be done in that respect, however -- which is not necessarily a bad thing, from my perspective. I do highly recommend the book to those interested in the nineteenth century.

Review # 2 was written on 2015-09-16 00:00:00 Heather Martz I found a lot of the detail in this biography fascinating; Bryant was one of the most famous Americans of his day, and today he seems to be almost completely forgotten. He was widely regarded as one of the best if not the best poet of the early to mid 19th century, he was the editor of an important NYC newspaper and met with practically every president from Jackson to Lincoln, he toured the world and published popular books...you would think that people would remember him. Bryant Park is named for him. But for whatever reason, he didn't last the way Whitman or Hawthorne or Melville or Cooper did. I did wish a few times in reading this that the author had broken away from a purely chronological biography though. It seems like Muller was just going through old issues of Bryant's newspaper, reading his editorials, and explaining what events in American history they related to. For the years where Bryant was writing in his paper every day, the 1840s and 50s, this just ends up being so much detail to cover. I don't really care about the intricacies of New York State party politics in the 1840s, knowing which candidate Bryant favored and why doesn't enrich this story for me. And all of Bryant's trips blend together as well; Muller could have just devoted a chapter to them, "Bryant's Travels," and been done with it. Every twenty pages or so it seems like he goes on another trip. I appreciated all the snippets of poetry mixed into the narrative, it helped the man come alive for me. But Muller also doesn't need to nudge the reader with praise for the poetry every time. I can decide for myself whether I like the poetry, I don't need the little authorial "he still could compose varying metrical rhythms, even at seventy!" Still, good biography for anyone who is interested in Bryant, or interested in America in that pre-Civil War period, when New York was growing like crazy and the country was expanding and everything was new and thrilling.