Blood meridian, or, The evening redness in the West Book

Cormac McCarthy's Blood Meridian is unquestionably the most violent novel I've ever read. It's also one of the best.

For those who would consider that a turn-off, I offer this caveat:
For the overwhelming majority of fiction that involves a lot of violence, the violence itself is an act of masturbation representing either the author's dark impulse or, perhaps worse, pandering to the reader's similar revenge fantasies (this might explain why the majority of Blood Meridian fans I know personally are men, where as the majority of those who've told me they were unable to finish it are women).

Don't get me wrong, the violence in Blood Meridian is gratuitous. It's both mentally and emotionally exhausting, even in a day and age where television and movies have numbed us to such things. But unlike, say, the movie 300, the violence serves a purpose - in fact the gratuitousness itself serves a purpose. Like how the long, drawn out bulk of Moby Dick exists to make the reader feel the numbingly eventless life of a whaling vessel before it reaches its climactic destination (McCarthy is frequently compared to Melville, btw), Blood Meridian exists to break the reader's spirit. Like the mercenaries the narrative follows, the nonstop onslaught of cruelty after cruelty makes us jaded. The story brings us to what we think is a peak of inhumanity that seems impossible to exceed, and just as we stop to lick our wounds, an even more perverse cruelty emerges. The bile that reaches the tip of our tongue at reading of a tree strewn with dead infants hung by their jaws at the beginning of the book (a scene often sited to me as the point many readers stop) becomes almost a casual passiveness when a character is beheaded later on. We become one of these dead-eyed cowboys riding into town covered head-to-toe in dried blood and gristle.

The story is based on My Confession, the questionably authentic autobiography of Civil War Commander Samuel Chamberlain, which recounts his youth with the notorious Glanton Gang - a group of American mercenaries hired by the Mexican government to slaughter Native Americans. Whether or not Chamberlain's tale is true only adds to the mythic quality - exemplified by the character of Judge Holden.

Blood Meridian is really The Judge's story. He is larger than life. Over seven feet tall, corpulent, hairless, albino, described as having an infant-like face and preternaturally intelligent. He is a murderer, child killer, pedophile and genocidal sociopath. But the question that plagues anyone who reads the book is - who is he really?

The easiest conclusion is that he is the devil, or some other demon. His joyous evil and fiddle-playing are enough clues to come to that, but more controversial (and less popular) is the idea that he is actually the wrathful God of an uncaring universe. He's called THE Judge, after all.

He spends a great deal of time illustrating new discoveries - be it an Indian vase or petroglyph - only to destroy it when finished. It's commented that he seems intent on "cataloging all creation". When a fellow mercenary asks why he does it, he smiles and cryptically replies "That which exists without my knowledge exists without my consent."

The fact that the book is rife with biblical imagery implies that he is more than a mere symbol of man's inhumanity to man (which is not to say that the devil isn't), but when the book ends ( SPOILER ALERT ) and our protagonist's body is found shoved into a commode, the townsfolk stand staring into the darkened doorway of the latrine, eerily mirroring the apostles staring into empty crypt after the resurrection. But here, there is no ascension; no salvation offered. Only the Judge, who dances to the closing lines, "He is dancing, dancing. He says that he will never die."