Sorting Out the Postal Strike Book

Like the Artscroll/Stone Chumash, this Chumash relies heavily on medieval Jewish commentators (such as Rashi, Nachmanides and Ibn Ezra) rather than adding one writer's unique perspective. But this Torah commentary has much less depth than Artscroll- where Soncino might dismiss a topic with a sentence or two, Artscroll will have a full paragraph. So on balance I like Artscroll better.

Soncino tends to be slightly less right-wing (in the sense of relying on bizarre legends) than Artscroll- but for a truly modern Orthodox perspective on the Torah, I like the Hertz Chumash better.